Timothy's Tikka House
Thankfully, I was wrong. I had a lovely channa masala with some good naan bread. Apparently, my dining companions were dying over the butter chicken as well.
The server was super-nice and very helpful; a very useful thing when you have a restaurant that barely seats 25. He was also awfully gracious, considering that we brought up the noise level in his restaurant up by about 10 million decibels by being there :)
There was some other stuff I wanted to try as well (aloo gobi! roti!), but didn't. Oh well, perhaps next time...